Q&A: Emotional Objections From A Non-Christian Friend

Hi Evan,

I am a Christian from Singapore.
My question is with regard to my conversations with my friend who is a skeptic/atheist.

She is very friendly and respects my faith, but whenever I bring up the issue of Christianity or Jesus Christ she will have strong objections-usually emotional, not logical.

I believe part of this may stem from her being offended by other Christians from the past who said she was “going to hell” or “may God reveal himself to you” etc. So she kind of thinks Christianity or all other religions for that matter have some agenda so they are not trustworthy.

The question I would like to ask you was the one she posed to me mainly(paraphrased):

“You Christians are very insensitive when going about telling others about your religion, especially if people like me don’t like/don’t believe in it. How would u like it if someone from another religion or an atheist kept on challenging your faith/belief about God?”

She has also compared the existence of God to unicorns (who do not exist) but I think the Kalam Cosmological Argument would answer that, just to confirm with you

I have read through many of ur blog posts and resources you quoted-and I have found them useful in defending the faith. I hope that you may be able to shed some insight on how to answer this challenging question, as it has a personal and emotional element to it.

Godspeed

Zhi Han(first name)

 
——————————————————————————————————–
 
 

First and foremost, I think you need to emphasize just how important it is that we know whether or not Christianity is true. I say this because she doesn’t really seem interested — I’m saying this based on how you described your interactions with her — as discussing the issue. She’s more or less like “Christianity is cool if it works for you, but don’t push it on other people who don’t care about it.” I don’t know if she accepts the idea of religious pluralism; that there are many pathways to God and God will accept us if we just “believe something sincerely” even if we’re sincerely mistaken, or if she thinks all religions are basically the same, or she doesn’t even believe truth is objective or can be known. These are all potential underlying factors that could possibly be driving her aversion to your sharing the gospel with her.

If she thinks there are many ways to God and He’ll accept us if we “Just believe something”, then you need to quote the words of Jesus to her where He said “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6) and “Unless you believe I am who I say I am, you will die in your sins.” (John 8:24, cf. John 3:36). Now, she can think Jesus is wrong or mistaken, but that is what Jesus said, and you believe Him. This is why you share the gospel with her, because you believe Jesus, you care about her, and you don’t want her to die in her sins. In other words, if Jesus is who claimed to be (and He is), her soul is in eternal peril. The punishment of the wicked dead in hell is described throughout Scripture as “eternal fire” (Matthew 25:41), “unquenchable fire” (Matthew 3:12), “shame and everlasting contempt” (Daniel 12:2), a place where “the fire is not quenched” (Mark 9:44-49), a place of “torment” and “fire” (Luke 16:23-24), “everlasting destruction” (2 Thessalonians 1:9), a place where “the smoke of torment rises forever and ever” (Revelation 14:10-11), and a “lake of burning sulfur” where the wicked are “tormented day and night forever and ever” (Revelation 20:10). God will send her there because, like all human beings, she has sinned and failed to perfectly keep God’s moral law (Romans 3:23, Romans 2:14-15), and that God is holy and just (Psalm 9:7-8, Psalm 9:16, Psalm 10, Psalm 11:16, Psalm 103:6) and therefore must punish her for her sins. Let her know though that God loves her deeply because He is love (1 John 4:8), and became a human (John 1:14) and died on the cross to take the penalty on Himself so that she wouldn’t have to endure it (Isaiah 53, John 3:16, 1 John 2:2, 1 Peter 3:18). Jesus suffered the wrath of God so that she wouldn’t have to suffer it. Let her know that if she confesses her sins and turns away from them, she’ll be forgiven and will be in right standing before God (1 John 1:9, Isaiah 55:7).

Ultimately, let her know that you (and especially God) care about her eternal destiny. Let her know just how much you want her to be with you and Him in Heaven for eternity. Let her know that you don’t want to annoy her or offend her, but you would rather be a little annoying then see her doomed to eternal destruction.

If she thinks all religions are the same so that she doesn’t any need in accepting your religion because she’d be just as well off accepting Buddhism or Judaism or Islam, because they are, after all, just like different colored M&Ms, then you can refute this by pointing out what these systems actually teach. Yes, there are some similarities in these, but these mostly have to do with morality. When it comes to the big metaphysical, worldview questions (i.e the nature of God, the nature of sin, the way to salvation, what the afterlife is like, et. al), they differ majorly! Either God is three persons like Christianity teaches or He’s 1 person like Islam teaches. Salvation is either a gift to be received or it’s something to be earned by doing enough good works or being reincarnated enough times to suffer through Karma, or something else. Jesus is either the Messiah like Christians claim or he’s not as adherents to Judaism claim. He’s either God in the flesh like Christians claim or He’s not as Jews, Muslims, Mormons, and Jehovah’s Witnesses claim. Religions are not like different colored M&Ms. They’re more like different medications in a medicine bag. And unless you read the directions, have the proper diagnoses, and pop the right pill, you could be in serious trouble!

 If She Thinks All Truth Is Relative, then simply ask “Is that a relative truth?” If she says “Truth is whatever is true for you. What may be true for you is not necessarily true for me?” ask her “Is that truth true for everybody or just you?” or “That’s true for you but not for me.” Relativism is ultimately self refuting. If it’s true that there is no truth, then it’s false that there is no truth. If “true for you but not for me” is true for everybody, then “true for you but not for me” is not just true for you but not for me because it’s true for everybody! Frank Turek likes to say that this will give you intellectual constipation if you think about it long enough.

So, Christianity is either true for everyone or false for everyone, but it can’t just be true for you but not for her. Jesus either objectively, in space and time, died on the cross and rose from the dead or He did not. God either exists or He does not. We’re either sinners in need of salvation or we’re not. A worldview either corresponds to the way the world really is or it does not.

“How would u like it if someone from another religion or an atheist kept on challenging your faith/belief about God?” — You can only answer this for yourself, Zhi, but as for me, I welcome challenges to my faith! For one thing, it helps me to build confidence in its truthfulness as I see Christianity continuously bombarded with criticisms and objections but see it emerge unscathed time after time after time. But for another thing, if I’m wrong, I want to know it! I don’t want to adhere to a system that’s not true. If I’m supposed to be a Mormon or Muslim, I’d like to know that so that Allah doesn’t send me to Hell for worshipping a man (Jesus). Or if atheism is true, I’d like to know that so I can stop praying to a figment of my imagination. Life is too short and eternity is too long to be wrong on questions about God, sin, salvation, and the afterlife.

“She has also compared the existence of God to unicorns(who do not exist) but I think the Kalam Cosmological Argument would answer that” — It absolutely would, Zhi. As would The Cosmic Fine-Tuning Argument, The Moral Argument, The Ontological Argument, and The Historical Case For The Resurrection Of Jesus, among many others.
 

I think your friend’s biggest problem may be some of the underlying conditions I noted above. You’d have to really get at the heart of her aversion to even talk about Christianity before you can start sharing the pieces of evidence that establish that it’s true. But, once you (and God) can get her to a place where’s she’s ready to talk, then you can appeal to these arguments to support your claim and win her over.

In my experience, unbelievers rarely read materials you give to them, but if she is willing, you could give her a copy of my book My Redeemer Lives: Evidence For The Resurrection Of Jesus which goes into detail the historical evidence undergirding Christ’s death on the cross and His resurrection from the dead, and how this entails that the Christian worldview is true. You can, if you want, read it in parallel with her and talk about the contents of each chapter like people do in a book club. But again, like I said, you need to address her underlying issues prompting her to avoid discussion before you do any apologetics. You need to essentially do PRE-pre-evangelism.
 
If you have any questions about Christian theology or apologetics, send Mr. Minton an E-mail at CerebralFaith@Gmail.com. It doesn’t matter whether you’re a Christian or Non-Christian, whether your question is about doubts you’re having or about something you read in The Bible that confused you. Send your question in, whatever it may be, and Mr. Minton will respond in a blog post just like this one. 
 
Liked it? Take a second to support Evan Minton on Patreon!

This Post Has 4 Comments

  1. Zhi Han Lim

    Hi Evan finally had time to get back to you. After talking to my skeptic friend, I am not pretty sure of she sees all religions as the same or truth as relative, although I do suspect it. She is generally tolerant of religion in general but gets uncomfortable when it is displayed publicly or what she perceives as “proselytion” by Christians.

    For instance she recently posted a meme on facebook that made fun of Jesus cursing the fig tree. When i tried to explain to her the historical context she wouldnt buy it and just said i was biased because im a christian. Even when i told her to google it. Then she accused believers like me of trying to “convert” her when I was just preventing her from making false statements of the Bible. Like, seriously? I understand she probably has emotional wounds from some over zealous christians but this is mind boggling.

  2. Zhi Han Lim

    Hi Evan hope u can reply to my comment as spon as possible

    1. Evan Minton

      My apologies for the late response. Things have been really busy lately. I’m not really sure what to tell you. If she isn’t even willing to LISTEN to the gospel or any arguments that Christianity is true, there’s nothing you can really SAY to MAKE her willing. I’m not sure what advice to give you except to pray for her. I think The Holy Spirit is really the only One who can help her.

  3. Zhi Han Lim

    Yeah,thanks. As u have mentioned on another article the point of apologetics is to point unbelievers to the truth of the gospel not to win arguments. I fear I was too carried away with the latter when responding to my friends arguments. I have to agree with u that the only thing we can do is to leave it to the Spirit.

Leave a Reply